| Places to Eat – 10/1/2023 |
| Place | Where | Rating (1-5) | Notes |
| Iggies Beach Bar | Bolongo | ? | |
| Mim’s Bistro | Bolongo | ? | |
| The Dive Bar | Compass Point | ? | Supposedly has a great burger. |
| SunnySide Cafe | Downtown | 5 | Great pizza, excellent view, easy parking. |
| Buddha Sushi Lounge | East end | ? | |
| Secret Harbour Beach Club | East end | 4 | Can also come in by charter boat. |
| French Quarter Bistro | Frenchtown | 4 | No outside seating, good food, extremely cold AC. |
| Frenchtown Brewing | Frenchtown | 5 | Co-located with Sunnyside Cafe at Bluebeards Castle. |
| Oceana | Frenchtown | 5 | Expensive, great views, good food. |
| Petit Pump House | Frenchtown | 3 | Cool view and people watching, mediocre menu. |
| Pie Hole | Frenchtown | 4 | Hit and miss, can be great pizza and calzones, sit outside because inside smells. |
| Twisted Cork | Frenchtown | 5 | Excellent food, great bar, protected parking. |
| Agave Havensight | Havensight | 5 | Generally terrible service across the board (5+ times), but outstanding food and easy parking. |
| Bar + Kitchen | Havensight | 5 | Unique food, top-tier drinks, not too pricey, easy parking. |
| Delly Deck | Havensight | 3 | One of very few breakfast places, easy parking. |
| Dog House Pub | Havensight | 5 | Best local bar on island, all NFL games. Great bar food & service. Bingo on Friday nights. |
| Cafe Amici | Downtown | 3 | Excellent pizza downtown, never busy, hard to park. |
| Tap N Still | Havensight | 5 | Excellent burgers, easy parking, hit and miss beer and service. Get the cold brew shot. |
| Denton’s Steakhouse | Limetree Beach | ? | Right next to Lanai, fancy steak house. |
| Lanai | Limetree Beach | 4 | Great for brunch, good views and easy parking. |
| Duffy’s Love Shack | Red Hook | 5 | Easy to park, fun drinks & good food. Terrible location. |
| Island Time Pub | Red Hook | 5 | Excellent pizza & view. Very hard to park. |
| XO Bistro | Red Hook | 3 | Easy to park, inside only. Good food. |
| Paradise Pie | Sapphire | 5 | Excellent pizza, great view, easy parking. |
| Sapphire Beach Bar | Sapphire | 5 | Great view, service, food, easy parking. |
| Glady’s Cafe | Waterfront | 2 | Locally-renown, not our style. |
| Parley Cafe | Waterfront | 5 | Best breakfast, hole in the wall. |
| Stone House Cafe | Waterfront | 4 | Great food, service and atmosphere, Cold AC. |
| Virgilios | Waterfront | 5 | Best Italian around. |
| 13 Restaurant | Yachthaven | 3.5 | Sit at the bar, hit and miss service but solid menu+, bad drinks. |
| Enkai Sushi | Yachthaven | 5 | 2nd best sushi, after 1864 on STJ. |
| St. Thomas Social | Yachthaven | ? | Brand new in 2/2023. Excellent views, expensive |
| St. John |
| 1864 Restaurant | St. John | 5 | Best place on the islands. Get the crab rangoon and oyster shooters. |
| Beach Bar | St. John | 5 | Great breakfast tacos. |
| Downstairs Bar | St. John | 4 | Cold AC for when it’s hot. Same everything as Upstairs Bar. |
| Greengos | St. John | 5 | Lots of TV’s, great food and margs. |
| North Shore Deli | St. John | 5 | Amazing sandwiches to take to the beach. |
| St. John Brewers | St. John | 5 | Excellent pizza – go to the photo booth. |
| The Longboard | St. John | 4 | Fun bar area, good food. |
| Upstairs Bar | St. John | 5 | Fun menu, good beer selection, good vibes. |
| Woody’s Saloon | St. John | 4 | Dive bar, great tacos. |
